What?
I’ve separated the skills from the attributes. Skills are
now completely separate from attributes. Each skill is now purchased
individually as its own trait in the same way you would purchase, say, Less
Sleep or Damage Resistance as their own standalone traits.
Why?
Six reasons.
1) The perverse incentives created by tying the
skills to the attributes.
GURPS makes it much more efficient to purchase skills by
jacking up one attribute (either DX or IQ) and then receiving the concomitant
skills at a low relative price.
The creates the incentive to focus entirely on one attribute
and the skills it governs, greatly punishing characters whose concept would
lead them to need multiple skills of different attributes.
Look at, for instance, the Dungeon Fantasy thief template.
It has to spread its points across DX and IQ. This is inefficient. It is much
better to have a character in the party with a high DX and another character in
the group with a high IQ. These characters can easily dip into the thief’s
skills. For a few points each, the DX- and IQ-based characters can easily
surpass the thief in the skills controlled by their attribute. For instance, a
swashbuckler who focuses entirely on raising their DX can far exceed the thief
in DX-based skill levels, while the same is true of a scholar who focuses on
their IQ and the thief’s IQ-based skills.
Under my proposed rules, this isn’t the case. A skill is a
skill is a skill. If you want the Stealth skill, you have to pay the points
specifically for the Stealth skill. These perverse incentives (which favor
certain character concepts—those concepts which focus entirely on skills
governed by a single attribute which they have raised to the heavens) are no
more. You can purchase the mix of skills that make the most sense for your
character without having to worry about attributes. This brings the incentives faced by characters
who would have formerly required a mix of attributes or a hodge-podge of
makeshift Talents into alignment with the characters whose builds don't face these same issues.
Further, it removes the incentive for players to make
characters that are focused entirely on the skills governed by a singular
attribute. No longer will characters be their choice of IQ or DX. They will
instead be characters, each with their own unique combination of skills.
It just doesn’t make sense to purchase IQ or DX scores of 11
or 12. Middling scores are nearly useless. Those levels of attributes don’t even
raise the skill level you receive when you spend a single point to a desirable
level. With IQ 12, my scientist still has to spend four points to get a
professional level in their main skill. The effect is that players pour all the
points they can into a single attribute to the detriment of everything else—or
they are punished when they have to work in a group where the other characters
have done so and then have higher defaults in skills that are intended to be
the primary focus of the other characters. My physician might end up
well-rounded, with all of their attributes at a slightly above average level,
and then skills at the low end of what is professional. Meanwhile, the
character in the party who purchased as high an IQ as possible is better at my
character’s niche than my character is. This creates a sort of arms race
between the characters where each character is little more than a mess of
points thrown into a single attribute. Only the rare character spends a large
number of points in a single skill, and when they do, it is invariably a combat
skill, which are the few skills in the game that are actually worth the four
points per level that GURPS charges for all skills. Which leads us into…
2) To allow for pricing individual skills
differently.
Guns. In most games where characters have access to modern
firearms, this is the most powerful skill in the game. Hobby Skill (Cup
Stacking). In most games where characters have access to modern firearms, this
is the worst skill in the game.
But you know what these two skills have in common? They both
have the exact same character point cost. To get either of these two skills at
the same level costs the same amount of character points.
This is bizarre. It makes no sense. Nowhere else in the game
do traits of such vastly different usefulness have the same cost. Imagine if
all leveled advantages had the same character point cost! Temperature Tolerance
and Altered Time Rate, for instance. Clearly this would be absurd. It is my
belief that what we have with the skill prices is exactly this absurdity.
Under my rules, the difference between the worst skills and
the best skills is that they cost a different price per level, exactly as with
Temperature Tolerance and Altered Time Rate. The difference is not so great as
between those two, of course, but the skills are priced according to the same
design philosophy.
3) So that we can vary the price of skills by
game.
Guns. In most games where characters have access to modern
firearms, this is the most powerful skill in the game. But not always. There
are plenty of game types where proficiency in the use of firearms is almost
entirely useless. Where a hundred sessions might go by without a single
opportunity for a character to touch a gun, let alone fire one. Romance games,
games about high school students, or even most games set in modern countries
where the characters just won’t have access to firearms.
In different types of games, different skills are useful. In
some genres, a certain skill is the best skill in the game, while in other
genres, it’s completely useless. Perhaps my starship captain is an expert
swordsman. That’s little more than a bit of color buried in his background. Yet
GURPS charges the same price for this skill in a game about starships as it does
in a murder mystery and a game about samurai duelists. This is problematic.
With my rules, the GM can easily change the price of a given skill to reflect
its usefulness in their game. If they want to run a game entirely about surfing
competitions, they can charge a
4) So you can make the character you want to
make.
This might just be me and the way I build characters, but whenever I build a character, I have an idea of what they look like in my head before I sit down to work up their character sheet. I know what their life has been like. I know what skills they've learned and what skills they haven't. And so when I sit down and begin work on my character sheet, one of the first things I do is write out what skills I want and at what levels. GURPS makes it very unpleasant to get those skills at those levels. I have to go through all the rigamarole of working out attributes, Talents, often multiple different skills defaulting to one another. It's such a drag. This process is at least ninety percent of the time it takes to build a character. And then, when I'm done, I often find that rather than ending up with the character I wanted, the incentives of the trait prices (namely DX and IQ) have pushed me away from a character who knows the skills I had in mind at the levels I wanted... to being a generalist with a high DX or a high IQ. And once you have a high attribute, you either have a high default in skills you didn't want to be good at, or (and I think this incentive is even worse) you end up facing the very small opportunity costs of expanding into skills you never wanted, but where the benefit you gain from changing your character concept (perhaps radically altering their backstory--in effect turning them into a different person) is so enormous that you end up doing it anyway. Once you reach the point where you can gain the most powerful skills at high levels for only a single character point each, then you're put into an impossible position. Either you buy them and destroy your character concept, or you don't buy them and feel like you're just wasting your character points. "Yeah, I guess I could have a high Guns skill essentially for free, but I won't." That's such a terrible position to be put in. It feels so bad. I think it's bad game design. I want to be able to build the character I want the way that I want and not get punished for it. In my house rules, I can do that.
5) Because that’s how real people learn skills.
Real people do not have attributes that govern their skills.
Humans have no intelligence score that makes them better at mathematics, chess,
piano, and diplomacy. You can’t get better at playing the piano by working to
become more intelligent. You can only become better at playing the piano by
practicing the piano.
And the same is true of the other attributes as well. People
who are more perceptive aren’t better at fishing or reading lips. People who
are good at fishing or reading lips are good at those things because they have
practiced those particular skills.
I think GURPS has this backwards. Someone isn’t good at
playing piano and giving speeches because they are intelligent. They are
intelligent because they have practiced many different skills, if we want to
think of intelligence as a meaningful concept at all.
Real people have skills that are at the level they have
practiced the skill up to.
As such, if you want to build a character that resembles a
real person, that’s very difficult in GURPS. It isn’t cost effective to build a
character who has a few skills at an increased level. The rules incentivize you
to buy up an attribute instead.
For example, if I had a character who was very good at
Fishing and Lip Reading, let’s say skill level 16 in each, then it is much more
cost effective for me to buy up their Perception than to purchase both skills
individual—even if that high Perception score doesn’t match my character
concept. The concept might be for a deaf fisherman who can read lips but who is
not otherwise super perceptive. GURPS penalizes this character concept by
making you pay more character points for less (you only receive the two skills
if you buy them alone, which should cost much less than buying up Perception,
which includes many other abilities, and also includes the two fairly useless
skills that you’re after here).
This becomes rather extreme in the case of IQ and DX, where
GURPS very strongly incentivizes the building of hypercompetent characters.
6) Streamlined Rules
Purchasing skills in GURPS is extremely complicated. You
must first decide what skill levels you desire and then reverse-engineer the
most cost-effective means of purchasing those skill levels. This likely results
in a morass of attributes, Talents, and skill purchases. This is by far the
most complex and time consuming part of creating a character. The complexity of
the way purchasing skills works is by far the biggest hurdle for new players
entering the game. They must learn how skills relate to attributes and Talents
and then internalize the incentives created by these arcane price schemes.
The Rules
Skills are now separate from attributes. Attributes have
nothing to do with your skill level. Each skill is instead assigned its own
price per level. You get all skills at a skill level of 8 and you buy them up
from there. The GM decides what the cost of each skill is per level based on
what they think it should cost for their game.
That’s it.
What? You’re still here? Fine. I guess I’ll go into a little
more detail.
First, these rules are meant to work with my house rules
where I greatly simplified the skill list. This isn’t going to work well (at
all maybe) with the default GURPS skill list. There are just too many skills
that relate to each other through defaults and there would be far too many
skills you would need to go through and determine your skill level in. It would
turn into a huge mess.
So, why a skill level of 8? The logical place to start is,
well, zero. I considered that. I think that would make the most sense. There
are a few problems there, though. First, there isn’t much mechanical difference
between a skill level of 1 and 6. Someone with that level of a skill isn’t
going to be able to effectively use it. The two are functionally the same. As
such, it would require a complex pricing scheme that would require a look up
table. It shouldn’t cost the same number of character points to go from skill 1
to skill 2 as it does to go from skill 11 to skill 12. I wanted to avoid that.
Another reason is that, at least for humans, it’s really trivially easy to
practice a skill up to a skill level of 8. If you look at my house rules, which
are based on the best empirical evidence I was able to gather, you’ll see that
it only takes five hours of practice to get to a skill level of 8. There is a
real difference there between a skill level of 7 and 8. My view is that pretty
much everyone who grew up in a society where the skill is regularly practiced
will have absorbed a skill level of 7 through osmoses. Someone who has never
touched a gun will have a skill of 7 just off what they’ve picked up through
watching movies and television. Someone who’s never argued a case in front of
a jury will have a skill of 7 from what they’ve picked up from… watching
television and movies. And so on. It’s just so easy to get to a skill of 7,
that I think we can treat everyone as having a skill level of 7 in every skill.
Note that this is much more generous than the rules as written, which give
0-point characters skill defaults ranging from 4 to 6 (with the strange case of
Brawling at skill 10). So I can see the argument for starting characters with
skill levels of 7 instead. It’s just so easy to go from 7 to 8, and of so
little consequence in most cases, and not worth even a character point, that
I’ve decided to forego all the hassle and just start the characters with skill
levels of 8 in all the skills. If the GM thinks you shouldn’t even have that
high a level of a skill, they can toss a familiarity penalty at you. I think
that’s the best way to handle that. If the GM looks at your backstory and
determines that your character has literally never touched a gun in their life,
they can give you a familiarity penalty to bring your skill level down to a 6
or 7 if they think that’s warranted.
Next up: the attributes. What happens with those? This is a
doozy. I’m saving that topic for another post. Suffice it to say that there
isn’t much left of IQ and DX once you start trying to price them without their
bonuses to skills. All in good time.
What else? How about an example. We’ll go with… hmm… what’s
a common genre? Medical mystery? Situation comedy? How about… medieval fantasy?
That work?
As I said earlier, I designed these rules with my skill list
house rules in mind, so that’s how I’m presenting them here.
These prices are only meant to function as an example of
what can be done with this skill pricing system, though I think there are certain
guidelines we can follow toward good skill prices. I think the best skills
should generally cost three or four points per level. Four points per level is
what GURPS charges for all the skills already, and it’s often a good idea to
spend a good many points raising one of the better skills. For instance, you
don’t feel as though you’re being ripped off when you spend forty points on
your swordsman’s sword skill. On the other end of the spectrum, we have the
worst skills. These are the skills that have no adventuring value whatsoever.
These are the skills that are of little use to characters who seek out and find
uses for them. Games is a good example of a skill such as this. Regardless of
how good your character is at playing chess, it’s not going to help that
character accomplish goals in most games. It would take a game specifically
tailored around playing chess to make the skill any good at all. Even in that
sort of game, chess might be worth three or even four points per level, but
other games, like go and backgammon, are still worthless.
So that gives us a pretty good guideline to work with, I
think: the best skills are three or four points per level. The
middle-of-the-road skills are two points per level. And the very worst skills
are one point per level. That’s what I’ve gone with here:
When looking at these
prices, don’t forget that characters start off with a skill of 8. So the first
level they purchase will raise their skill to 9, then 10, and so on.
Skill Name
|
Cost
|
Animals
|
|
Animal
Handling†
|
2
|
Fishing
|
1
|
Art
|
|
Artist†
|
1
|
Dancing
|
1
|
Disguise†
|
2
|
Erotic Art
|
1
|
Musical
Composition
|
1
|
Musical
Instrument†
|
1
|
Performance
|
1
|
Singing
|
1
|
Writing
|
1
|
Business
|
|
Accounting
|
2
|
Administration
|
2
|
Business †
|
2
|
Combat
|
|
Melee
Weapons †
|
4
|
Shield
|
4
|
Cloak
|
2
|
Unarmed
Striking
|
3
|
Grappling
|
3
|
Bow
|
3
|
Sling
|
2
|
Throwing
|
2
|
Craft
|
|
Armoury†
|
2
|
Butchering
|
2
|
Carpentry
|
2
|
Cartography
|
2
|
Cooking
|
2
|
Counterfeiting
|
2
|
Engineering
|
2
|
Farming
|
2
|
Jeweler
|
2
|
Leatherworking
|
2
|
Machinist
|
2
|
Masonry
|
2
|
Mechanic†
|
2
|
Prospecting
|
2
|
Sewing
|
2
|
Smith
|
2
|
Gaming
|
|
Games†
|
1
|
Hobby
Skill†
|
1
|
Sport†
|
1
|
Influence
|
|
Deception
|
3
|
Diplomacy
|
3
|
Intimidation
|
3
|
Oratory
|
3
|
Savoir-Faire†
|
3
|
Sex Appeal
|
3
|
Intellectual
|
|
Architecture
|
2
|
Astronomy
|
2
|
Biology
|
2
|
Chemistry
|
2
|
Connoisseur
|
2
|
Cryptography
|
2
|
Expert
Skill†
|
2
|
Geography†
|
2
|
Geology†
|
2
|
Heraldry†
|
2
|
History†
|
2
|
Law
|
2
|
Mathematics
|
2
|
Meteorology†
|
2
|
Pharmacy†
|
2
|
Philosophy
|
2
|
Physics†
|
2
|
Physiology†
|
2
|
Religious
Ritual
|
2
|
Research
|
2
|
Theology†
|
2
|
Medical
|
|
Diagnosis†
|
2
|
Physician†
|
2
|
Surgery†
|
2
|
Military
|
|
Intelligence
Analysis
|
2
|
Battle
Command
|
2
|
War
Planning†
|
2
|
Movement
|
|
Acrobatics
|
2
|
Climbing
|
2
|
Escape
|
2
|
Jumping
|
2
|
Swimming
|
2
|
Survival
|
|
Foraging
|
1
|
Fire-Starting
|
1
|
Knot-Tying
|
1
|
Nativation†
|
1
|
Tracking
|
2
|
Vehicles
|
|
Crewman
|
2
|
Marine
Vessel
|
2
|
Riding†
|
2
|
Miscellaneous
|
|
Area
Knowledge†
|
2
|
Body
Language
|
2
|
Fast-Draw
|
2
|
Holdout
|
2
|
Lip
Reading
|
1
|
Lockpicking
|
2
|
Teaching
|
1
|
Theft
|
2
|
Loading
|
1
|
Now that we have the rules, let’s try a sample character. A
quick fantasy background…
Our character is Gerald, a farmer-turned-mercenary who was
drawn into a life of crime by one of his mercenary companions after the war. He
now lives as a petty thief, pickpocket, and conman in the big city of Fantasiport.
So what I’ll do is look through the list of skills and jot
down the ones I think I want to purchase for him. This would be much easier
with a paper printout of the skill list with their detailed prices. I would
need only make a mark next to each skill to indicate my desire to purchase that
skill. Then I could later decide my skill level and write it down on the list.
This way, I would be able to easily know my level in every skill with a mere glance
at my sheet.
From his youth as a farmer I give him:
Animal Handling (Pigs)
Butchering
Farming
Area Knowledge (Homeland)
From his days as a mercenary, I give him:
Melee Weapon (Edged Weapons) - 4/level
Shield - 4/level
And from his recent time as a ne’er-do-well in the city he
has:
Games (Dice)
Deception
Stealth
Area Knowledge (Fantasiport)
Theft
Now I need to decide on the skill level he has in these
skills and how many points those are going to cost.
I decide on:
Animal Handling (Pigs)-9 [2]
Butchering-9 [2]
Farming-10 [2]
Area Knowledge (Homeland)-9 [2]
Melee Weapon (Edged Weapons)-11 [12]
Shield-10 [8]
Games (Dice)-9 [1]
Deception-11 [9]
Stealth-10 [6]
Area Knowledge (Fantasiport)-9 [2]
Theft-11 [6]
Bringing the total cost of his skills to 52.
